Need some aid choosing

Hi! I’ve had some free time lately and have always wanted to try playing a string instrument.

After some research on YouTube, I’ve come across three options:

  • Ukulele: It seems beginner-friendly, smaller, and more affordable, but I worry it might be too limited.
  • Electric Guitar: I love the sound, but it looks quite intimidating and expensive to get started.
  • Acoustic Guitar: This seems to be a middle ground between the two. I like the sound, but I’ve heard electric guitar strings are gentler on the fingers than acoustic ones.

I’m having trouble deciding among these options. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

It sounds like you’re most excited about the electric guitar, and it’s really not any more intimidating than the other options. The higher cost is mainly due to needing an amp, but you can actually get a great amp simulation on your PC for much less. While some people on this forum may dislike amp sims, they’ve significantly improved in quality over the past few years.

Personally, I’d recommend getting an electric guitar along with a simple and affordable interface, like a Behringer Guitar Link, and then using software like Amplitube 5. This setup would cost under $150 USD and will provide a far superior sound compared to a real amp at that price point.

When selecting a musical instrument, choose one that resonates with you personally. While ukuleles are essentially small acoustic guitars and can be charming, I’d suggest considering electric guitars for their versatility and extensive sound options through pedals. However, they can be more expensive to start with. Regardless of your choice, avoid low-quality instruments. Invest in a reputable brand, as they generally offer better playability and tuning stability. Additionally, have the intonation professionally adjusted when you first get it to ensure smooth playability.

Don’t stress about the strings hurting your fingers initially—it’s a normal part of learning. Instead, concentrate on building finger strength through regular practice and exercises, even if it’s just 5-10 minutes a day.

I don’t want to invest too much initially since I’m not sure if I’ll enjoy it right away. My budget can go up to 300€ (I’m in Europe). I’m interested in genres like grunge, nu-metal, and alt-rock.

Would you recommend buying a second-hand guitar? Since I’ve never played an instrument on my own, I’m unsure if I’ll stick with learning.